View full version

«Mykolaiv Parks» will pay over ₴100,000 in compensation to the owner of the car onto which a dangerous branch fell

«Миколаївські парки» виплатять понад ₴100 тис. компенсації власниці авто, на яке впала аварійна гілка. Ілюстративне фото з відкритих джерел«Mykolaiv Parks» will pay over ₴100,000 in compensation to the owner of a car onto which a fallen branch landed. Illustrative photo from open sources

The Zavodskyi District Court of Mykolaiv has ordered the municipal enterprise «Mykolaiv Parks» to pay the owner of a Volkswagen Golf over 116,000 hryvnias in compensation.

This is stated in the court ruling of 12 November, according to NikVesti.

The incident took place on 24 July. The car was parked between a residential block and a shop. As a result of the falling branch, the windscreen and the rear right-hand window of the car were smashed, dents formed on the bonnet, and scratches appeared on the roof. During an inspection of the scene, law enforcement officers established that the acacia branch was rotten on the inside.

The car’s owner brought a claim against the municipal enterprise «Mykolaiv Parks» in court. Initially, she demanded 112,900 hryvnias in compensation for material damage and 10,000 hryvnias in compensation for distress from the enterprise.

The municipal enterprise contested the claim. It stated that during inspections of trees posing a hazard—which could have been identified by their external appearance—no such trees had been found. A representative of the municipal enterprise also noted that the branch had green leaves and that its internal rot only became apparent after it had fallen.

During the court proceedings, a transport and goods expertise was ordered. It established that the cost of repairing the car would amount to over 143,000 hryvnias. However, the car owner subsequently reduced her claim to 95,600 hryvnias for material damage and withdrew her claim for compensation for non-pecuniary damage.

Meanwhile, on 2 November, a representative of «Mykolaiv Parks» filed a statement with the court acknowledging the claim and agreeing to pay the compensation sought.

The court established that the plot of land on which the tree stood was municipal property, and that the municipal enterprise was responsible for the condition of the greenery on it. The court also referred to the regulations on the maintenance of green spaces, which require the identification of hazardous trees, in particular those with rotten tree trunks.

Consequently, the court upheld the claim and ordered the company to pay the car owner 95,622 hryvnias in compensation for material damage, as well as 21,123 thousand hryvnias to cover the costs of assessing the damage, conducting the expert examination and court fees.

NikVesti previously reported that in Mykolaiv, the owner of a Mercedes-Benz is seeking, through the courts, over 198 thousand hryvnias in compensation from the municipal enterprise «Mykolaiv Parks» for damage to her car caused by a falling tree. This is the cost of repairing the car, as preliminarily assessed by an expert.

View full version